I am neither the first nor the last to compare the politics of present-day America to that of the late Roman Republic and the early days of Empire.
But the Imperial Presidency did not begin with Trump. Its roots go back decades. And most recently, before Trump there was Joe Biden.
Imperial, you ask? The progressive, Democratic President?
You bet. The New Yorker‘s article reveals why. Not in power grabs or grandeur, but in its insularity, the stage-managed image, and the systemic shielding of the President’s decline.
When Biden showed up in the summer of 2024 at a fundraising event hosted by George Clooney, “Clooney knew that the President had just arrived from the G-7 leaders’ summit in Apulia, Italy, that morning and might be tired, but, holy shit, he wasn’t expecting this. The President appeared severely diminished, as if he’d aged a decade since Clooney last saw him, in December, 2022. He was taking tiny steps, and an aide seemed to be guiding him by the arm. […] It seemed clear that the President had not recognized Clooney. […] ‘George Clooney,’ [an] aide clarified for the President. ‘Oh, yeah!’ Biden said. ‘Hi, George!’ Clooney was shaken to his core. The President hadn’t recognized him, a man he had known for years.”
Yet, Biden was shielded. His true condition was kept hidden even from members of his own party. Those around him — perhaps out of a sense of kindness, a sense of misguided loyalty — chose to gaslight their party, their country, the world. They even gaslighted Biden himself — encouraging him, by assuring him instead of making him face the stark truth in one of his clearer moments.
When Biden finally stepped down, it was too late. Instead of Kamala Harris, we are now dealing with a second Trump presidency.
And thus, here we are: First, a combination of Obama and Biden, resembling both the young, transformative Augustus and the same Emperor in his later years of frailty and decline, hidden by aides from the public; followed by a President resembling some of the worst Rome had to offer in the later Empire, like Caligula and Nero and Commodus combined.
To use a tired but still valid cliche: History doesn’t repeat; but it sure as hell rhymes.
There is no button “+1” or rather “+100”, so I put it verbally: this all echoes my thoughts! I don’t remember if I already mentioned this, but I lamented Mr.Biden and his colleagues not letting Ms.Harris to rule for some months before elections. I guess this happened (in slightly different manner) with Theodore Roosevelt in the past and it was to the good. God knows I was much wishing Ms.Harris to win, at least “for a change” and for the first woman here (and somewhat different from most aged ladies in US politics).
And yep, there are dozens of parallels to Roman Empire. Including, for example, widening of “sphere of influence” while degrading internally etc. I should go and re-read Momsen’s “History of Rome” – probably it was the most adequate case of winning Nobel prize in literature.
Some things still look differing though. For example, who is really ruling? Not “Praetorian Guard”, neither some single omnipotent person (doomed to be killed in the Capitol).