Was I being prophetic?
Before he became known for his support for conspiracy theories, including birtherism, accusations concerning George Soros, or climate change skepticism, Lou Dobbs was a respected CNN financial news anchor, known for his daily show, Moneyline.
In late 2002, Dobbs asked viewers for their opinion concerning the name of the new, about-to-be-established Department of Homeland Security.
I wrote to the show in response, although I never received a reply. Here’s what I had to say:
From: "Viktor T. Toth" <vttoth@vttoth.com>
To: <moneyline@cnn.com>
Subject: Naming the Department of Homeland Security
Date: Tue, 19 Nov 2002 03:50:05 -0400
Message-ID: <03e501ce6507$f7a846a0$e6f8d3e0$@vttoth.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain;
charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
X-Mailer: Microsoft Outlook 14.0
Thread-Index: AQFMd4u4HjxK217e2sZcPfYto6R+JQ==
X-OlkEid: 41640A693654140EFCFE274493B534253EDD2699
Dear Lou:
You asked... so here is what I think.
What a Homeland Security Department should be called depends on whether
you're referring to the role it should play, or the role it'll likely play
(I fear) in American society. To the former, I have no suggestions,
because I don't think there's room for a Homeland Security Department in
America in the first place. To the latter: well, you don't have to invent
anything new. Plenty of names can be borrowed from history. How about
Geheime Staatspolizei? Or do you prefer the more multicultural Ministry of
the Interior? Committee of State Security perhaps, better known by its
ominous three-letter Russian acronym? Or going further back in history,
would Comité de Sureté Public be more appropriate?
Whatever the new Department will be called, I fear that one day its name
will be listed on the pages of history books along with all these other
venerable institutions designed by their esteemed founders to protect the
helpless public from itself.
Are my fears unfounded? I don't even live in your country, yet I have
second thoughts about sending this e-mail to you. Having grown up behind
the Iron Curtain, my very genes tell me that it is a bad idea to stick my
neck out like this: lay low, enjoy the good life, and don't bring
attention to yourself, that's what my Communism-bred genes are screaming
right now. But this is the Land of the Free, right? So I should suffer no
harm for speaking my mind, and my fears regarding the new Department are
just the silly ideas of a crazed immigrant Canadian... right? Right???
Viktor Toth
Ottawa ON CANADA
As I am reading about ICE detentions, weaponizations of the Justice Department or the FBI, voluntary self-censorship by news organizations, vindictive presidential actions against Harvard, intimidation of judges and a whole host of other shenanigans taking place in the United States today, I wonder if I actually underestimated the dangers back then, a little less than 23 years ago.